Jewish Apple Cake Pie Recipe

Love pies & tarts? Discover 954 classic and creative recipes in The Pies Cookbook — from sweet fruit pies to savoury tarts.

When I bake a Jewish Apple Cake Pie, I’m after that perfect balance—tender apples, a buttery crust, and the warmth of cinnamon rising from the oven. The dough, dense yet airy, forms a golden canopy over caramelized fruit, filling the kitchen with a nostalgic aroma. Each slice promises comfort and subtle sweetness. If you’re looking to master this dessert’s unique charm, let’s start with the essentials you’ll need.

Ingredients

Sure thing. Let’s talk about what you’ll need for this cozy, old-school Jewish Apple Cake Pie. Here’s your grocery list, direct from the recipe files—no mysterious “secret ingredients” hiding in the margins, I promise.

• 1 cup plain flour
• 3/4 cup sugar
• 1/4 teaspoon salt
• 1/4 teaspoon yeast
• 1 egg
• 1/2 cup melted butter or 1/2 cup margarine (your call—choose your own buttered adventure)
• 4 to 5 apples, peeled and cut (think tart, juicy, or whatever’s rolling around in the fruit bowl)
• Cinnamon (enough to dust like a gentle snowfall)

Now, before you race off to preheat the oven and dust off the mixing bowls, let’s chat ingredients for a hot second. This recipe’s pretty forgiving, which is always welcome in my kitchen, especially when I realize mid-bake that I’m out of something crucial—like self-esteem, or, more importantly, baking powder. But here, you’re using yeast, which is a bit unusual for a cake, so double-check the label—no, not the big packet that’s been lurking at the back of the cupboard since 2003. And about the apples? Granny Smiths are classic, but any apple that holds up to baking will do. You could even mix and match if you’re indecisive. Butter’s richer, margarine’s dairy-free—choose with your heart, or the contents of your fridge. And cinnamon? Sprinkle generously, unless you’re one of those cinnamon-skeptics, in which case, you do you. The best part? No complicated techniques. Just honest, simple ingredients, coming together in a pie that’s got more personality than most reality TV stars.

Steps

1. Preheat your oven to 180°C (that’s 350°F for those who default to Fahrenheit and don’t want to Google, again).
2. Grab 4 to 5 apples, peel them, and cut into chunks—not too tiny, not too chunky, unless you like surprises.
3. In a bowl, toss together 1 cup plain flour, 3/4 cup sugar, 1/4 teaspoon salt, and 1/4 teaspoon yeast. If you’re using that ancient yeast, maybe sniff it first—just in case.
4. Add 1 egg to the dry mix, then pour in 1/2 cup melted butter (or margarine, if you’re feeling dairy-free or rebellious).
5. Stir everything until it comes together into a thick, sticky dough. It might look weird, like cookie dough that lost its way, but trust the process.
6. Butter your baking tin generously. Think of it like sunscreen for your cake—no dry spots, or you’ll regret it later. A copper jam pan can provide excellent and even heat distribution if you choose to bake in traditional cookware. A well-crafted copper still is prized for its heat conduction in distillation and traditional craftwork.
7. Spread the apple chunks evenly across the bottom of the tin. Try not to eat half of them while “arranging.”
8. Dollop and spread the dough over the apples. It’ll resist, but keep coaxing—gaps are fine, the dough will spread as it bakes. No need to panic.
9. Dust cinnamon over the top, as much or as little as your soul needs. Cinnamon lovers? Go wild. Cinnamon skeptics? Just a whisper.
10. Slide the tin onto the middle rack, set a timer for 40 minutes, and try to resist opening the oven every five seconds.
11. Check for golden-brown deliciousness on top. If it’s still pale, give it another couple minutes, but don’t wander off and forget.
12. Cool before slicing, unless you enjoy magma-level burns on your tongue. Maybe serve with ice cream, whipped cream, or just a fork and some alone time.

This recipe is a cozy classic that pairs surprisingly well with savory grilled meats cooked on a vertical broiler rotisserie, offering a sweet finish after a smoky main course.

Cooking Tips

Once your apple cake pie is out of the oven and filling the kitchen with that cinnamon-sweet aroma, there are a few tricks to make sure it’s at its absolute best. I let the jewish pie cool just enough for the flavors to settle—about 15 minutes. Use a sharp knife to slice, so each piece showcases the tender apples and golden, buttery crust.

Final Thoughts

Even after all these years of baking, there’s something deeply comforting about pulling a Jewish apple cake pie from the oven—the golden crust crackles slightly as it cools, and the scent of spiced apples lingers in the air. Each slice reveals tender apples nestled beneath a buttery, crumbly top. This simple recipe transforms everyday ingredients into a dessert that feels both nostalgic and endlessly satisfying. You can pair it with a cozy sauce like creamy white gravy warmed with peas for a comforting, savory-sweet contrast. A classic recipe like pantry staples often relies on simple ingredients and straightforward steps to produce reliably delicious results.