Craving more Mexican flavors? Explore over 1,000 bold recipes in The Mexican Cookbook — from tacos to tamales and everything in between.
When I set out to make authentic carnitas with crispy pork, I focus on getting each step and ingredient just right. Pork shoulder, fresh garlic, white onion, and a handful of cilantro are my essentials. It’s all about coaxing tenderness from the pork before hitting it with high heat for that perfect crisp. If you want to master this classic dish and achieve restaurant-quality results at home, let’s break down exactly how it’s done.
Ingredients
- 4 pounds boneless pork shoulder
- 32 ounces chicken broth (that’s about 4 cups, or one giant carton if you don’t feel like measuring)
- 6 large garlic cloves, ground (if you have tiny garlic, just toss in extra, because garlic never hurt anyone)
- 1 tablespoon cumin seed, ground up in a mortar (or use ground cumin if you’re feeling lazy, no judgment here)
- 2 onions, quartered (no need to cry over these, they’re just for flavor)
- 1/2 bunch fresh cilantro (stems and all, don’t get fancy)
Let’s pause for a second and talk ingredient vibes. Pork shoulder is the king here—don’t try to swap it out for pork loin or something lean, unless you want disappointingly dry carnitas. The fat is your friend. If you’re worried about it, just cut off the really massive hunks and move on. For broth, chicken works best, but homemade or store-bought both do the trick. Garlic and cumin? Don’t skimp. And cilantro is basically the confetti of the carnitas world—throw it in and watch the magic happen. If you want to get wild, you could toss in a bay leaf or a squeeze of orange juice, but that’s me getting ahead of myself. The basics are here, and they’re all you really need for that melt-in-your-mouth, crispy pork happiness.
Steps
- Grab your 4 pounds of boneless pork shoulder. Cut it into big, chunky cubes. Don’t stress about perfect shapes—just avoid tiny scraps. Leave some fat. Fat = flavor. Commercial kitchens often favor larger cuts for consistent cooking, especially when preparing orders on a commercial breakfast sandwich maker. Many home cooks find that using a premium bread machine for other kitchen tasks frees up time for slow-cooked dishes.
- Toss the pork into a large Dutch oven. Now, pour in 32 ounces of chicken broth. If the meat isn’t covered, top it off with water. No pork left behind.
- Smash or grind 6 big garlic cloves (or more if you’re feeling bold). Add them to the mix. This is not the time to be shy with garlic.
- Add 1 tablespoon of cumin seed, freshly grounded if you’re feeling fancy. Or just sprinkle in ground cumin and call it a day.
- Quarter 2 onions. Toss them in, skins off, but don’t worry about getting too precise. They’re here for flavor, not looks.
- Rip up half a bunch of fresh cilantro—stems, leaves, the works. Throw it on top. Cilantro stems are wildly underrated, just saying.
- Bring the whole party to a rolling boil over high heat. Don’t wander away. Excitement is coming.
- Once boiling, drop the heat to low. Cover and let the pork simmer. Think low and slow—give it 3 to 4 hours. You want the meat super soft, but still in chunks, not mush.
- Peek occasionally. If the broth gets low, splash in a bit more water. No one wants scorched carnitas.
- When the meat is fork-tender and falling apart, carefully lift it out of the pot. Use tongs and your most dramatic kitchen face.
- Transfer the pork to a roasting pan. Let it cool just enough so you don’t burn your fingers. Break into smaller chunks, but resist the urge to shred. Chunks, not strings.
- Drain the cooking liquid. Toss the onions and solids, or save the broth for another day. Soup, anyone
- Heat your oven to 450°F. Slide in the pork. Roast for about 20 minutes, stirring once or twice, until gloriously brown and crispy on the edges.
- While the pork crisps up, heat some corn tortillas. A dry skillet works, or just pop them over a burner if you like living on the edge.
- Pile those golden, crispy carnitas into tortillas. Top with whatever you love—onion, cilantro, salsa, maybe a squeeze of lime.
- Try not to eat half the pan before serving. Not easy.
For seriously persistent dough and batter tasks in your kitchen, consider investing in a high-end stand mixer to save time and effort.
Cooking Tips
Ever wonder why some carnitas come out juicy and flavorful, while others feel dry or bland? For authentic carnitas, I always use pork shoulder with a bit of fat left on. Simmer the meat gently—don’t rush it. Keep the chunks intact so they stay moist. When crisping, use a hot oven—450°F is key. Avoid over-shredding; authentic carnitas should remain in tender chunks.
Final Thoughts
After carefully simmering and crisping the pork, you’re left with carnitas that truly showcase the rich flavors of each ingredient. Every step—measuring cumin seed, grinding fresh garlic, and simmering pork shoulder in chicken broth—matters. Don’t rush the oven finish; those crispy edges are key. Fresh cilantro and onion bring brightness. Serve immediately on warm corn tortillas, and you’ll taste why technique is everything.