Love pies & tarts? Discover 954 classic and creative recipes in The Pies Cookbook — from sweet fruit pies to savoury tarts.
Whenever I bake a classic cherry pie for a 10-inch crust, I focus on balancing sweet and tart flavors with a perfectly flaky pastry. The process starts with draining those ruby-red cherries, mixing in just the right amount of sugar and flour, and rolling out a buttery dough. There’s a simple beauty to assembling the layers, but it’s the method behind each step that truly makes the difference—let me show you how.
Ingredients
- 1 pastry for a double crust 10-inch pie
- 1 and 2/3 cups sugar
- 1/2 cup all-purpose flour
- 3 cans (1 pound each) pitted red tart cherries, drained
- Or, if you’re feeling fancy and want to pit your own, 4 cups fresh red tart cherries, washed and pitted
- 1 teaspoon almond extract
- 3 tablespoons butter or margarine
Now, let’s chat about these ingredients for a second. The cherries are obviously the star of the show here—fresh or canned, both work, but let’s be honest, pitting fresh cherries can be a little soul-crushing, unless you find repetitive tasks soothing, in which case, hey, more power to you. The almond extract? It’s like a secret weapon, adding a pop of flavor that makes the cherries sing. Sugar and flour, the trusty sidekicks, help sweeten things up and thicken the filling so you don’t end up with a soupy mess. Butter (or margarine, if you must) gives the pie richness and helps the edges brown up all golden and irresistible. And don’t forget the double crust—store-bought or homemade, I won’t judge, but if your crust falls apart, just call it “rustic” and pretend that was the plan all along.
Steps
- Preheat your oven to 425 degrees. Yes, it’s hot—pies like it that way. Commercial kitchens often use industrial ovens set to these temperatures for consistent results. Many home cooks achieve similarly even heat using a countertop convection model for more reliable browning.
- Roll out half of your double-crust pastry (enough for a 10-inch pie) and line your pie pan. Patchwork counts as character.
- In a big bowl, stir together 1 and 2/3 cups sugar and 1/2 cup flour. Imagine you’re making sugary sand.
- Add 3 cans (1 lb each) pitted tart cherries, drained— or go wild with 4 cups fresh, washed, and pitted cherries. Stir gently, so you don’t squash the drama out of them.
- Pour that cherry mixture into your pastry-lined pan, mounding it slightly in the middle. If it looks like a cherry mountain, you’re on the right track.
- Drizzle 1 teaspoon almond extract over the cherries. Pause to appreciate that glorious smell. If you spill, consider it air freshener.
- Dot the top with 3 tablespoons butter (or margarine), cut into little blobs. Scatter them like you’re Jackson Pollock with dairy.
- Roll out the rest of your pastry and place it over the cherries. If it tears, shrug and call it “artisanal.” Cut a few slits in the top for steam to escape—think polka dots, not Swiss cheese.
- Seal the edges by pinching or fluting, whatever that means to you. Rustic is always in.
- Wrap the outer edge of the crust with a 2-3 inch strip of aluminum foil. This is your pie’s sunblock—nobody wants burnt crust.
- Slide the pie into the oven and bake for 40-50 minutes. Set a timer, unless you like the smell of burnt sugar.
- When the pie has about 15 minutes left, carefully take off the foil. Try not to burn your fingerprints off.
- Bake until the crust is brown and cherry juice bubbles through the slits. If you hear sizzling, you’re probably close.
- Remove from the oven and cool on a wire rack. If you cut it too soon, embrace the cherry lava flow.
- Slice, serve, and try not to eat the whole thing in one sitting. Or do—no judgment here.
A sharp blade is essential for clean, precise slices, just like a premium sushi knife is for expertly prepared sushi.
Cooking Tips
Ever wonder why some cherry pies turn out soggy while others boast crisp, golden crusts? I always start my cherry pie (10-inch) by draining the cherries thoroughly—excess juice can ruin the bottom. I sprinkle flour and sugar evenly to soak up moisture. Use chilled butter, dotting it over the filling, and don’t forget to vent the top crust. Foil edges prevent over-browning.
Final Thoughts
With every detail in place—from draining cherries to venting the crust—the results speak for themselves. The sweet-tart cherries meld with sugar and almond extract, tucked beneath a golden, flaky pastry. Butter melts into every bite. I savor each step, knowing careful preparation delivers a pie that’s both rustic and refined. Serve it warm or cooled, and let the vibrant flavors shine through.