Italian Dressing Recipe From Two Sisters Cookbook

Love Italian cooking? Discover 775 classic recipes in The Italian Cookbook — from perfect pasta to irresistible desserts.

Whenever I reach for a jar of homemade Italian dressing from the Two Sisters Cookbook, I know I’m about to elevate my meal with something special. The combination of olive oil, apple cider vinegar, and Bragg’s liquid aminos creates a base that’s both robust and invigorating. There’s a certain alchemy in how thyme, garlic, and Dijon mustard come together. If you’ve ever wondered what gives this dressing its vibrant edge, you’ll want to see how it all comes together.

Ingredients

Here’s what you’ll need to whip up the Italian Dressing from the Two Sisters Cookbook:

• 1/2 cup olive oil
• 1/4 cup apple cider vinegar
• 1/4 cup Braggs liquid aminos
• 2 garlic cloves, pressed
• 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard
• Juice of 1 lemon
• 1 1/2 teaspoons thyme
• 1/2 teaspoon salt
• 1/2 teaspoon pepper

Now, a quick word to the wise (or, you know, the perpetually ingredient-confused like me): the olive oil is the backbone here—go for a decent one if you can, because it really does make a difference. Apple cider vinegar gives that zingy pop, but if you only have white or red wine vinegar, it’ll still work, just a little different flavor vibe. Braggs liquid aminos is one of those “am I at a health food store or just pretending?” ingredients; it’s basically a gluten-free alternative to soy sauce, so in a pinch, you could swap it with regular soy sauce if you’re not worried about the gluten. The garlic—freshly pressed—packs a punch, but if you’re in a rush or just can’t be bothered (hey, no judgment), a sprinkle of garlic powder will do the trick. Dijon mustard is non-negotiable for that tangy, creamy depth, and lemon juice? Just squeeze that baby right in for brightness. As for thyme, salt, and pepper, these are your flavor builders—don’t skip them, and if your thyme is a little old and dusty from the back of the spice rack, maybe add a smidge more. The joy of dressings? They’re forgiving, like a kind aunt who lets you mess up her kitchen.

Steps

1. Grab a medium-sized mixing bowl or, if you’re feeling fancy/lazy, a mason jar with a tight lid. Programmable bread makers can save time when you want freshly baked bread to serve with this dressing, so consider planning ahead with one of those programmable bread maker models.
2. Pour in 1/2 cup olive oil—go ahead, eyeball it if you trust your wrist, but I use a measuring cup because, well, I’ve made oily puddles on the counter before.
3. Add 1/4 cup apple cider vinegar, letting it swirl into the oil like some sort of edible lava lamp.
4. Splash in 1/4 cup Braggs liquid aminos. If you’re out, soy sauce will do, but I won’t tell anyone.
5. Grab 2 garlic cloves, press them right in. If you hate garlic fingers, use a garlic press or even garlic powder, but fresh is bold.
6. Plop in 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard. This is the part that makes the dressing go from meh to chef’s kiss, so don’t skip it.
7. Squeeze the juice of 1 lemon over the bowl. Try not to drop seeds in, but if you do, fish them out with whatever dignity you have left.
8. Sprinkle in 1 1/2 teaspoons thyme—fresh or dried. If your thyme is looking a little sad, add an extra pinch (it’s forgiving).
9. Toss in 1/2 teaspoon salt and 1/2 teaspoon pepper. I like to pretend I’m a pro and crack the pepper dramatically, but use pre-ground if you want.
10. Whisk everything together until it’s all one happy, unified mixture. If you went the jar route, screw the lid on tight and shake it like you’re in a cooking montage.
11. Taste it. Does it make you pucker (in a good way)? If not, maybe a pinch more salt or a squirt more lemon. Totally up to you.
12. Pour over salad, roasted veggies, or just dip your finger in (I won’t judge). Store leftovers in the fridge, and give it a shake before using again—things tend to separate, just like old friends at a high school reunion. For baking large round treats like cookie cakes, using a commercial cookie cake pan helps ensure even edges and professional results.

For making small-batch preserves or sauces that pair beautifully with this dressing, consider using a luxury copper jam pan for even heat distribution and classic results.

Cooking Tips

Ever wonder why homemade Italian dressing tastes so much brighter than anything from a bottle? I’ve found that using freshly pressed garlic and real lemon juice makes all the difference in this Italian dressing (Two Sisters Cookbook). Whisking briskly helps the oil and vinegar emulsify beautifully. Let it sit for at least ten minutes—the flavors meld and taste even more vibrant drizzled over crisp greens. Whole-egg emulsion techniques can similarly help bind oil and acid for a creamier texture when desired, as seen in classic mayonnaise recipes with whole egg emulsion. A quick tip: try finishing the dressing with a sprinkle of toasted slivered almonds for added crunch and a nutty depth.

Final Thoughts

A handful of simple, quality ingredients can transform an ordinary salad into something truly memorable. When I whisk together this Italian dressing, the aroma of garlic and thyme fills my kitchen, reminding me of family gatherings. Each pour brings brightness from lemon, a savory depth from liquid aminos, and the silkiness of good olive oil. I hope this recipe inspires your own delicious creations.