Sugar Cookie Recipe From 2009

Love baking cookies? Find 1,849 irresistible recipes in The Cookies Cookbook — from classic chocolate chip to creative creations.

When I look back at the sugar cookie recipe from 2009, I notice how it bridges old-fashioned methods with a bit of modern convenience. The mix of cold butter and Crisco isn’t something you find in earlier recipes, but it gives the dough that unmistakable tenderness. The use of cream of tartar and those festive sugars brings a sense of nostalgia, yet also hints at how traditions adapt. But there’s more behind each ingredient choice—let’s explore what sets this version apart.

Ingredients

• 1/2 cup cold butter
• 1/2 cup Crisco (yep, the classic stuff)
• 2 cups white sugar
• 1 teaspoon baking soda
• 1 teaspoon cream of tartar
• 1/8 teaspoon salt
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 3 large egg yolks (just the yolks, not the whole egg)
• 1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
• Red and green decorating sugar (for rolling)

Now, let’s chat about these ingredients for a second. You’ll notice it asks for both cold butter and Crisco, which is like the ultimate tag-team when it comes to texture—think melt-in-your-mouth but with just enough chew. Don’t try to swap one for the other, unless you enjoy living dangerously or have a thing for rebellious cookies that spread into mysterious shapes. The sugar, well, there’s a lot, but that’s what makes them sweet enough to bribe Santa or your siblings. Cream of tartar and baking soda? They’re the unsung heroes, giving the cookies that magical soft-yet-tender bite. And yes, you only want the egg yolks. It feels weird tossing out the whites, but trust the process. Vanilla is the soul of the cookie, so go for the real stuff if you can. And those colored sugars? Optional, but why not add a little sparkle—unless you’re a cookie minimalist, then feel free to rebel. Just remember: ingredients matter, and sometimes, even the smallest pinch of salt can make you feel like a pro baker, even if your apron is covered in flour and existential dread.

Steps

1. Preheat your oven to 300°F. Low and slow, like a lazy Saturday. Line flat, rimless cookie sheets with parchment. Trust me, you’ll want that parchment. No one likes scraping fossilized cookie off a pan. Premium kitchen tools like a well-balanced knife can make prep safer and more efficient, especially when trimming decorations or ingredients with precision; consider investing in a high-end sushi knife for superior control. Smart Bread also reviews programmable bread maker features that help maintain consistent temperatures and baking performance.
2. Grab 1/2 cup cold butter and 1/2 cup Crisco. Throw both into a bowl. Cold—yes, you read that right, not room temp. Cream them together for about 40 seconds, just until they look like awkward roommates forced to share a space. Don’t overmix. They’re not BFFs.
3. Add 2 cups white sugar to the bowl. Mix just until it’s a grainy, weird mash-up. Do not keep beating like you’re mad at your ex. Just until combined.
4. Sprinkle in 1 teaspoon baking soda, 1 teaspoon cream of tartar, and 1/8 teaspoon salt. This trio is like the secret band behind the cookie’s greatest hits. Give it a quick mix.
5. Pour in 1 teaspoon vanilla extract. Inhale, and pretend you’re in a fancy bakery. Mix it just enough so the vanilla doesn’t feel left out.
6. Time for egg yolk drama: Separate 3 large eggs and add only the yolks. No whites allowed. Mix gently, like you’re tucking a baby into bed.
7. Add 1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour. Dump it in all at once, then mix just until a dough forms. Don’t overwork it. The dough should look like Play-Doh but less neon. If it’s crumbly, gently smoosh it together.
8. Now, roll dough into balls a little bigger than a hazelnut, but smaller than a walnut. Somewhere in that “why do I have these nuts in my pantry” zone.
9. Pour red and green decorating sugar (as much as your holiday spirit can handle) into shallow bowls. Roll each dough ball in the sugar until it looks like it fell into a glitter factory.
10. Place the sugar-coated dough balls on your parchment-lined baking sheet, about two inches apart. Give them some personal space. No one likes clingy cookies.
11. Bake for 12 to 14 minutes. But here’s the trick: At 12 minutes, they should look puffy, pale, and maybe a little underdone. The bottoms should be golden, but not brown. If you see brown edges, you went too far. These cookies are like introverts: they need to exit the oven before things get too heated.
12. Let the cookies cool on the pan for a few minutes. They’ll deflate a little and firm up, which is basically the story of adulthood.
13. Once cool (or, you know, not lava-hot), transfer to a wire rack. Admire your work. Eat one. Or five. No judgment.

High-end tandoor ovens offer authentic clay-lined cooking for superior heat retention and smoky flavor, making them a great choice for serious home chefs who want restaurant-quality results and authentic tandoor cooking.

Cooking Tips

Ever wonder why this 2009 sugar cookie recipe calls for both cold butter and Crisco? Cold butter hails from European baking, lending flakiness and rich flavor, while Crisco—a product of 20th-century American innovation—adds tenderness and prevents spreading. Historically, older sugar cookie recipes relied solely on lard or butter. By blending both, sugar cookie 2009 achieves a texture and taste that bridges tradition and modern convenience. The same crowd-pleasing approach shows up in entertaining recipes like Mini Potato Baskets topped with smoked salmon and toasted capers, which use a 20-ounce package of shredded hash browns to form 24 crisp mini-muffin potato cups. Vegetarian recipes such as bulgur chickpea burgers also rely on thoughtful ingredient combinations to balance texture and flavor, using flax egg as a binder when forming patties.

Final Thoughts

Understanding the ingredient choices in this 2009 sugar cookie recipe reveals more than just baking technique—it connects us to a broader culinary lineage. Using both butter and Crisco echoes mid-20th-century baking trends, while cream of tartar recalls even older traditions. These choices shape texture and flavor, bridging past and present. Baking these cookies, I’m reminded how recipes evolve, yet still ground us in shared, nostalgic experiences.